Productivity and Health of Three Northern New York Lakes
Thursday, October 15, 2020Celia Diller and Aidan Callahan
Productivity and Health of Three Northern New York Lakes
Brad Baldwin
December 18, 2018
Introduction
We examined lakes in different areas of northern New York to compare and contrast their community structures, habitat traits, and the ecosystem productivity and health. There are many reasons to do such a study of comparing multiple lakes. One such reason is for conservation, meaning by studying multiple lakes, we can understand what factors make up a healthy lake ecosystem. Comparing a large lake with lots of human development around it, such as Black Lake, to a small lake with little human development, can reveal different factors of the lake ecosystem in response to size and development (Figure 1). Similarly, looking at a lake within the Adirondack Region, Massawepie Lake, and one in the St. Lawrence River Valley, Black Lake, or Sylvia Lake, can show different levels of health and productivity that can be attributed to their locale. For example, the Adirondack Region has been known to experience acid rain, so you would expect the pH to low in Massawepie lake compared to those in the River Valley.
Figure 1. A map of the study lakes and landscapes of northern New York. The pink circle is Canton, New York. The red lines are circling the St. Lawrence River. The yellow circle is Massawepie Lake. The green circle is Sylvia Lake. The Blue circle is Black Lake. The light blue line outlines the boundary of the Adirondack Park with the park located right of the line.
Methods and Materials
We began the study of these lakes in the late summer from September-October. We studied Massawepie on the 4th of September on a fairly sunny day between 20-30℃. There was a slight breeze and the previous weather had been warm, with an hour of rain the previous day. We studied Sylvia on the 18th of September on a cloudy day. There was a slight breeze and the temperature was around mid 20s℃. Lastly, we studied Black Lake on the 27th of September and it was fairly sunny with a high of 14℃.
We sampled two different ecological zones in the three lakes: the pelagic zone and the littoral zone. The littoral zone at Massawepie Lake showed visible vegetation near the shoreline. There were many different native plants, small fish, and insects. The littoral zone went to about 1.5 m deep into the lake. The littoral zone in Sylvia Lake showed less native species than in Massawepie Lake, with the invasive submerged aquatic vegetation (SAV’s) Eurasian Milfoil heavily distributed over the littoral zone of Sylvia Lake. In Black Lake, the littoral zone was a shallow 0.33 m deep and the lake floor was not visible with very abundant vegetation and phytoplankton. In Massawepie Lake, the pelagic zone we measured was around 15.18 m whereas the pelagic zone that we measured in Sylvia Lake was around 21.13 m and in Black Lake was around 3.81 m.
A key to understanding ecological structures was measuring habitat zonation in the pelagic zone, the largest realm of the lake. We assessed the chemical, physical, and biological conditions of all three lakes by measuring vertical profiles of temperature, chlorophyll a, dissolved oxygen, salinity, and pH using a Hydrolab Sonde. We also used light penetration as a measurement to zone the habitat between the photic zone and the aphotic zone with a LiCor light meter attached to the Hydrolab Sonde. The edge of the photic zone was the depth where 1% of the surface light was penetrating the lake.
We assessed the abundance and vertical distribution of phytoplankton by looking at the Chlorophyll a measurements from the Hydrolab Sonde and taking samples of water with a Van
Dorn sampler. We also assessed the abundance and vertical distribution of zooplankton using zooplankton nets with 350 or 64 µm mesh towed vertically through either a shallow depth within the photic zone or a deep depth (photic zone and part of the aphotic zone) to catch zooplankton. This was done to test whether zooplankton abundance differed between the two zones of the lake. In Sylvia Lake, the shallow depth was around 7.5 m and the deep depth was around 15 m. In Massawepie Lake was about 5.6 m and the deep depth was around 15 m and in Black Lake, the shallow depth was 1.5 m and the deep depth was 3 m. Based on the number of zooplankton caught per tow, we could find out if their distribution was relatively equal throughout or showed some sort of pattern possibly related to the chlorophyll a numbers we found from the Hydrolab Sonde. If, for example, the zooplankton are found to be more abundant within the shallow tows and chlorophyll-a measurements are highest above the photic zone, we could guess that the high zooplankton abundance is a response to the chlorophyll a, which signifies phytoplankton.
Results/Discussion
Another of our goals was to determine the ecosystem productivity of the lakes. We compared our results from our chlorophyll a, Secchi disk depths, and total phosphorus to those in Table 1, to know what stage of production our lake was in. Highly productive lakes are in the Eutrophic stage, moderately productive lakes are Mesotrophic, and lowly productive lakes are in the Oligotrophic stage. Before taking any measurements, in Massawepie Lake we saw a lot more SAV’s and darker water so we assumed that it was slightly eutrophic. On the other hand, Sylvia Lake had very clear water and showed little SAV’s outside of the areas where Eurasian Milfoil growth was being controlled by humans. This made us presume the lake to be oligotrophic. Black Lake was very green and had very little visibility, if any, to the lake floor, so we assumed the lake to be highly eutrophic. To get the Secchi disk depth measurements, we extended the Secchi disk into the water until it was no longer became visible. In addition, we compared the total phosphorus measurements from previous years to determine the amount of nutrients available to plant life and phytoplankton in each lake. In Massawepie Lake, the total phosphorus was 0.015 mg/L, in Sylvia Lake, the total phosphorus was measured to be 0.008 mg/L, and in Black Lake, the total phosphorus was 0.07 mg/L. Phosphorus is a limiting nutrient in the photosynthetic organisms so higher mg/L is good for the growth of such organisms.
Table 1: Criteria for assessing lake productivity of Massawepie, Sylvia, and Black Lake.
To estimate the ecosystem health of the lakes, we took more of the measurements from the Hydrolab Sonde such as the dissolved oxygen (D.O.), specific conductivity (SPC), and pH. We also took samples of the lake water and tested its hardness as well as its acid neutralization capacity (A.N.C.). Hardness was tested by using a LaMotte Water Hardness test kit which gave us the parts per million of calcium carbonate. A.N.C. was tested by adding 0.05 M of hydrochloric acid to samples of the lake water until the pH decreased to about 4.2. We then used the formula below to get the A.N.C. (mg CaCO3/L).
MCaCO3(sample) = (2 MHCl * VHCl)/VCaCO3 (sample)
These measurements were compared to the USEPA ratings of lake health. Ultimately these readings show the ability of the lake to sustain life. Dissolved oxygen is important for the fish that inhabit the lake, so higher numbers are good and keep fish happy. Mean SPC and A.N.C. show the lake water’s ability to withstand acidification. The pH has a small range (6.5-9) within which biota of temperate lakes are comfortable living in.
Table 2. Comparison of the EPA Classification of ecosystem health to the estimates found at Massawepie, Sylvia, and Black Lake.
Temperature showed zonation as did light in Massawepie and Sylvia Lake. Black Lake, on the other hand, had light zonation but temperature was uniform due to the shallowness and the constant mixing of the polymictic lake (Figure 3). Different temperatures created an epilimnion (upper layer), metalimnion (middle layer), and hypolimnion (lower layer) in Massawepie and Sylvia Lake whereas light created aphotic and aphotic zone in all three lakes. Because Sylvia Lake has a larger depth and was more oligotrophic, according to the EPA Classification, it had a much deeper photic zone (15.85 m) than the other lakes that reached well below the hypolimnion (Figure 3). Massawepie photic zone (5.55 m) also reached into the Metalimnion but only by about half a m (Figure 3). Black Lake’s photic zone was close to the surface of the lake (1.16 m) due both to the relatively shallow depth in comparison to the other two lakes and the eutrophication.
Chemical measurements such as Phosphorus were found within all lakes, as is stated in Table 1 and although we didn’t measure Nitrogen, it is more likely than not found in all the lakes as well. However, we can only assume the density at which it is found. Based on the productivity of each lake, we can guess that Black Lake had the highest amount, followed by Massawepie and then Sylvia Lake. We can also guess that phosphorus and nitrogen were found at high densities in the hypolimnion of Sylvia lake due to the large spike in chlorophyll-a measurements and high D.O., likely signifying the presence of an algal plate (Figure 4, Figure 5).
Related, the biochemical measurements we took, such as chlorophyll-a, dissolved oxygen, and specific conductivity, showed zonation in Massawepie and Sylvia Lake whereas in Black Lake these measurements were generally uniform throughout the lake (Figure 4, Figure 5, Figure 6). Specific conductivity (SPC) was highest in Sylvia Lake and lowest in Massawepie (Figure 6). Both Sylvia and Black lake had very high SPC measurements, staying the 200s uS/cm, which is likely to do with their watershed geology (Figure 6, Figure 7). The watershed geology of Sylvia is completely Sedimentary, which means ions are constantly being released into the water, and similarly, Black Lake has a highly Sedimentary watershed geology that applies ions whereas Massawepie has a completely Metamorphic and Igneous watershed geology that releases very little ions to the water(Figure 7).
Chlorophyll a, which can also be referred to as phytoplankton, showed to be highest right above the furthest reach of the photic zones in all lakes except Black Lake (Figure 4). Black lake, which due to its shallowness only has an epilimnion, had the highest amount of phytoplankton below its photic zone, contrasting the other two lakes (Figure 4). It is possible that due to us studying the lake after a windy weather event and the lake being polymictic, the phytoplankton which would accumulate in the photic zone stirred and we caught it on a day when the phytoplankton had just been mixed below the photic zone. As was stated earlier, Sylvia lake has a very large blimp that is located in the hypolimnion, which can mean many things (Figure 4). For one, there is a high nutrient content there as was stated earlier, or two, phytoplankton don’t mind or even prefer cooler temperatures in the Sylvia Lake. There is also the possibility that nutrients are so sparse in the upper layers of Sylvia Lake, that phytoplankton undergoes Photoinhibition, a decrease in the capacity to perform photosynthesis due to outside stresses, such as limited nutrients. Massawepie showed a less extreme version of Sylvia, with a blimp in phytoplankton recorded above the photic zone within the Metalimnion (Figure 4). We can also guess that right above the photic zone contains enough light to perform photosynthesis, but enough light where they are also less visible to predators.
Dissolved Oxygen in Sylvia Lake showed a blimp-like the chlorophyll a measurement but at a slightly higher depth due to oxygen being a byproduct of the blimps of phytoplankton performing photosynthesis (Figure 5). In Massawepie Lake, we also see D.O. is high above the blimp of chlorophyll-a we measured, but it continues to increases until the surface (Figure 5). This is possibly due to the surface to air interface which adds oxygen to the water, or can be attributed to phytoplankton being more active closer to the surface, or even a combination of the two. Dissolved Oxygen in Black Lake showed uniform D.O. at all depths but very slightly increased closer to the surface (Figure 5). This is most likely a result of the polymictic mixing and the surface to air interface releasing oxygen into the uppermost areas of the lake. The dissolved oxygen in Massawepie and Sylvia lake steeply decrease in the hypolimnion due to detritivores breaking down the dead matter and using up the D.O. there.
![]() |
Figure 5. Vertical Profiles of dissolved oxygen (mg/L) measurements at various depths (m) in (A) Massawepie Lake, (B) Sylvia Lake, and (C) Black Lake.
Figure 6. Scatterplot of special conductivity (uS/cm) measurements at various depths (m) in (A) Massawepie Lake, (B) Sylvia Lake, and (C) Black Lake.
There is likely to be a 2 story fishery in Massawepie and Sylvia lake where there was a wide temperature difference between the upper layer and lower layer (Figure 3). Fish such as the Large and Smallmouth Bass as well as forage fish are going to be found in the warmer upper layer of the lake. Benthic Omnivores, such as the catfish and suckerfish will be found towards the bottom layer of the lake. Lake trout, which prefer colder waters, will also be found in the deeper, cooler hypolimnion of the lakes. In addition, the dissolved oxygen content is higher at the top portion of the lake (Figure 5). This is helpful for fish such as the large and smallmouth bass who need the higher dissolved oxygen levels. Black Lake is likely to have a 1 story fishery with its uniform temperature throughout (Figure 3). Even so, Black Lake has a much larger variety of fish in it than either of the other two lakes. This is likely to be a result of the sheer size of Black Lake and its watershed (Figure 7) and its uniform temperature and D.O. (Figure 3, Figure 5). There are more ecosystems in the Black Lake watershed that feed into it, which means a wider variety of fish can also feed into it. The uniform D.O. is also high which is good for any fish (Figure 5). Temperature was also uniform and high so a high fish abundance is likely an indicator that fish prefer this (Figure 3).
Phytoplankton appeared more abundant in the upper layer with the warmer water and higher dissolved oxygen. This correlates with reality due to the chlorophyll a being mostly from phytoplankton that needs the light of the upper layer to perform photosynthesis which gives off oxygen as a byproduct. We expected more zooplankton to be near where the phytoplankton was more abundant. In Massawepie, we found that using the 350 mesh net we did 5.6 m tows and found that around 58,940 and 45,364 (#zoopl/m^3) were present in the shallow end. In the deep end, the 15 m tows showed around 23,531 and 21,115 (#zoopl/m^3). In Sylvia Lake, we found that using the 350 mesh net we did 7.62 m tows and found that around 180 and 267 (#zoopl/m^3) were present in the shallow end. In the deep end, the 15 m tows showed around 290 and 310 (#zoopl/m^3). Zooplankton aren’t strictly found in just the upper layer for a number of reasons. One being that their food also includes protozoans, which are not limited by light so they can be found throughout the different depths of the lake. Another reason is that zooplankton’s main predators, such as forage fish, are very visual and thus zooplankton would try to stay in darker waters in order to hide from these fish. However avoid, it is more likely that the zooplankton’s main source of food in this lake is phytoplankton and the vast majority will take the risk of being seen by their own predators. While zooplankton could avoid being seen by predators in the hypolimnion, they would not be able to get the amount of food they need on a daily basis.
All three lakes had different levels of productivity (Table 1). We estimated that the lake productivity of Massawepie Lake was roughly mesotrophic with a medium total phosphorus and low, but within the mesotrophic level chlorophyll-a numbers. The Secchi disk depths showed a near eutrophic level, but still within the mesotrophic level (Table 1). Sylvia Lake was oligotrophic, even though its chlorophyll a count was within mesotrophic levels. The total phosphorus was well within oligotrophic levels as was the Secchi disk depth (Table 1). Black Lake was eutrophic, but with an average chlorophyll a measurement in the mesotrophic level (Table 1) These findings coincide with what we hypothesized by observing the status of the lakes at the first site. However, if we were to look at the different depths of each lake in comparison to chlorophyll a measurements we could find that certain sections are different than the average. For example, the chlorophyll-a measurements within the presumed algal plate of Sylvia Lake reach as high 8 ug/L which is eutrophic, and the same could be said for the blimp in chlorophyll a in Massawepie and Black Lake(Table 1, Figure 4). We can also look at the shallow epilimnion and deep hypolimnion in Massawepie Lake, where chlorophyll-a measurements reach below 2 ug/L which is considered oligotrophic (Table 1, Figure 4). Due to the somewhat developed shoreline of Sylvia Lake, it seemed completely possible for the lake to be more productive due to human waste and runoff coming from the homes and camps surrounding the lake. This was of course not the case, and that could be because of the extreme depths of the lake or the fact that the people around the lake have solid septic systems. When it came down to it, Sylvia Lake had much less development around itself than Black Lake, which also had more than 4x the human density within 100 m (Figure 7, Table 3). Massawepie on the other hand had little development around its shores (a summer boys camp) and 0 humans within 100 m (Figure 7, Table 3). Although development didn’t have a large effect on the production of Sylvia, we can guess that if more development were to come to Massawepie, the lake would become more eutrophic/productive.
Table 3. Lake morphology and Human Presence of Lakes within New York State.
We found Massawepie to be a less healthy ecosystem on average than Sylvia Lake, as was Black Lake. The mean dissolved oxygen of Massawepie (4.925 mg/L) was just below the EPA’s healthy number for fish of 5 mg/L, whereas Sylvia had an average of 10.23 mg/L (Table 2). Black Lake’s D.O. was lower than Sylvia but above the healthy number for fish (Table 2). Even though Sylvia was less productive, its dissolved oxygen content more than doubled Massawepie’s (Figure 4). This is possibly a result of higher levels of decomposition occurring in Massawepie. Also, if we look at the epilimnion of Massawepie lake, the D.O. there is above the healthy for fish number (Figure 5, Table 2). Massawepie had a pH of 6.737, just within the EPA’s 6.5-9.0 suitable for biota range (Table 2). Its SpC was averaged at 48.188 uS/cm, which is slightly above the EPA’s range for sensitivity to pH decline (<40) but had an A.N.C. of 57.237 mg/L which is well below the EPA’s range for sensitivity to pH decline of <200 (Table 2). This means that if enough acid rain were to come down upon Massawepie, it's already near danger zone of pH could lower and cause problems for the biota of the lake. Sylvia on the other hand had a pH of 7.22, SPC of 218.18 uS/cm, and A.N.C. of 277.37 mg/L (Table 2). This shows that Sylvia is not likely to succumb to pH decline and thus its biota can remain alive and healthy. There is a likely correlation between this ability to sustain pH and the watershed geology (Figure 8). Sylvia Lake was located near a Talc mine and has only sedimentary rock within its watershed geology (Figure 8). Due to sedimentary rock’s softness and ease of breaking down, many ions are placed into the water which creates a better buffering capacity. This is why Sylvia is not susceptible to pH decline and why it has a high SPC average. Massawepie, on the other hand, has a large metamorphic/igneous rock watershed geology which is hard and doesn’t give off a lot of ions to combat pH acidification (Figure 7). Thus Massawepie is susceptible to pH decline and has a low SPC average. Black lake has a very basic pH of 9.2, which is out of the comfortable for biota standard (Table 2). It also has a very high SpC, but a low A.N.C., so different aspects show a likelihood that Black is both susceptible to pH decline (A.N.C.) and not susceptible (SPC) (Table 2). However, due to its already basic waters and large size, it is not likely to decline in pH (Table 2, Table 3).
Figure 8. The watershed geology percentages of (A) Massawepie Lake, (B) Sylvia Lake, and (C) Black Lake.
Figure 9. Food Webs of (A) Massawepie Lake, (B) Sylvia Lake, and (C) Black Lake
All three of the lakes share the same fundamental food webs as each other, with the exception of the number and type of players in each trophic level. There are primary producers, primary consumers, secondary consumers, and so on, with the addition of bacteria and protozoans and the nutrients used by bacteria and the primary producers. Phytoplankton and algae make up the majority of the primary producers, with S.A.V. playing a smaller role. However, they do apply habitat for young juvenile fish and the like. Zooplankton and insects are the primary consumers that feast upon the primary consumers, protozoans, and bacteria. Above them are planktivorous fish, such as juveniles and smelt, as well as mussels, if they are present. Then comes the piscivores, who are primarily the game fish, that everyone wants to catch. These include bass and pike species. Humans and birds apply another layer to the food web as well above the piscivores. Black Lake has by the far the most species of fish present, whereas Massawepie and Sylvia share a similar number of species (Table 4). This is one reason Black Lake has a high human population around because of its capacity to make money for fishing with its many fish species (Table 3, Table 4).



























